The Weekend Muck: July 2, 2023
From leaked documents proving the United Way is extorting the sexual data of local children from area nonprofits, to city council rolling back the property tax millage rate saving taxpayers $7 million, to the city wasting countless resources so 24 people can drive golf carts across Veterans Parkway, here’s all the muck that’s fit to print from the Columbus, Georgia area, along with a look at what to expect in the week ahead.
The Weekend Muck is your look at all the muck that’s fit to print from the Columbus, Georgia area, brought to you by Muscogee Muckraker. Image source: Muscogee Muckraker
Image Credit:
Muscogee Muckraker

Are we on the right path as a city? What are your thoughts as the reader? Be sure to follow Muscogee Muckraker on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter to see our upcoming stories as they break throughout the coming week.

COLUMBUS, Ga. — From leaked documents proving the United Way is extorting  the sexual data of local children from area nonprofits, to city council rolling back the property tax millage rate saving taxpayers $7 million, to the city wasting countless resources so 24 people can drive golf carts across Veterans Parkway, here’s all the muck that’s fit to print from the Columbus, Georgia area,  along with a look at what to expect in the week ahead.

LEAKED: DOCUMENTS PROVE UNITED WAY IS FORCING ORGS TO ASK LOCAL KIDS ABOUT SEXUALITY OR LOSE FUNDING

This story was originally published on June 26, 2023.

An artistic expression of Ben Moser, President of the United Way of the Chattahoochee Valley, beside Erika Cottingham, CFO/COO, superimposed on a colorized image of the organization’s building at 1005 Front Avenue in Columbus, Georgia. Leaked documents now prove the local United Way of the Chattahoochee Valley is forcing Columbus nonprofits to either collect data on the sexuality of local children or lose their funding. Image source: Muscogee Muckraker

COLUMBUS, Ga. — Leaked documents including funding contracts now undeniably prove that the United Way of the Chattahoochee Valley is forcing local Columbus nonprofits to either ask local children about their sexuality or lose the United Way’s funding.

The documents were obtained by the Muckraker from local Columbus-based nonprofits that exclusively serve children.

Back on June 13, we broke this story after hearing compelling evidence from several of those local nonprofits. The corroborated accounts all included the same descriptions of how a new funding contract from the United Way was now forcing them to collect data on the sexuality of the children they serve. If those local nonprofits did not provide the United Way with the data, the United Way would no longer fund the local nonprofit organization, effectively extorting them to either provide the data or go broke.

As a result, many of those local nonprofits turned to the Muckraker in hopes of shedding light on the problem for them. We were — and are — more than happy to oblige. 

Before we dive into the documents, it is important for the reader to understand that the United Way has already embarrassingly been caught in an outright lie by denying their requirement of the data.

You can read more towards the end of this article about how the local United Way flat-out lied to city council’s face — on camera — for the entire world to see. 

First, here’s the proof. It really helps paint a better picture of how despicable the UWCV’s cover-up was as they knowingly lied to city council’s face in hopes of no one finding out about this. 

Lucky for them, we at the Muckraker happen to specialize in exposing such malevolence.

Explore the full story to see the documents for yourself, along with how the United Way knowingly lied to City Councilors’ faces in an effort to cover it up.

TAX ASSESSOR BASED PROPERTY VALUES ON OLD DATA; RIGGED HIGHER VALUES DESPITE LAW

This story was originally published on June 27, 2023.

An artistic expression of The Columbus Consolidated Government’s Chief Appraiser, Suzanne Widenhouse, superimposed on a colorized image of the June 20 city council meeting. Widenhouse recently admitted to creating property tax assessments for the current tax year using market data from up to three years ago during the peak of the pandemic’s inflationary housing market, despite state law requiring assessments to be made using conditions from the current tax year. Image source: Muscogee Muckraker

COLUMBUS, Ga. — Muscogee County’s Chief Appraiser, Suzanne Widenhouse, openly admitted to using market data that was up to three years old when developing property tax assessments for the current tax year, despite state regulations requiring property values to be calculated based on the conditions in the year they are to be taxed.

The admission was made several times — on camera — during a line of questioning from city councilors during the city council meeting held on June 20.

During the council meeting, several city councilors began to ask Widenhouse very blunt questions regarding the methodology of how her office arrived at such inflated property values for so many property owners here in the Fountain City. 

Through that line of questioning, Widenhouse brazenly stated that her office never “catches up” on current market conditions to make property valuations, but instead uses data that is between one and three years old.

Explore the full story to see how your property tax assessments have been rigged using data from the peak of the pandemic so that the city manager can use the inflated value to put more of your money into his budget.

CITY COUNCIL ROLLS BACK PROPERTY TAX RATE; SAVES TAXPAYERS $7 MILLION

This story was originally published on June 28, 2023.

An artistic expression of iconography representing property taxes, superimposed on a colorized image of the Columbus, Georgia city council meeting held on June 27, 2023. After weeks of heated debate, city council unanimously voted to decrease the property tax millage rate, keeping $7 million in the hands of taxpayers and out of city coffers. Image source: Muscogee Muckraker

COLUMBUS, Ga. — “Little else is requisite to carry a state to the highest degree of opulence from the lowest barbarism but peace, easy taxes, and a tolerable administration of justice: all the rest being brought about by the natural course of things.” — Adam Smith. 

Columbus residents can rest a bit easier now that city councilors have unanimously voted to lower property taxes throughout the Fountain City.

During the city council meeting held on June 27, the Muscogee County property tax millage rates were lowered to keep a grand total of $7 million in the pockets of taxpayers, as follows:

  • General Services: 1.03 mills reduction;
  • Indigent Care: 0.41 mills reduction.

The reductions equate to annual savings for every homeowner throughout the entirety of Columbus.

According to Finance Director Angelica Alexander, the average $375,000 home in Urban Service District 2 would see an annual savings of $170 per year while slightly smaller $200,000 homes in Urban Service District 1 would save $70 per year.

While those numbers may seem small for the average homeowner, it makes a big difference in keeping rents from skyrocketing throughout the city — which would otherwise greatly contribute to increased poverty, crime, and blight. 

That same millage rate decrease is a much bigger relief to commercial property owners and landlords who were recently slammed with huge valuation increases, as the reduction now saves them — and their renters — amounts in the tens and even hundreds of thousands of dollars per year in property tax bills.

 With lower taxes, landlords aren’t forced to increase rents for their tenants, who in turn keep more of their own money in their own pockets. That, in turn, leads to fewer evictions, greater stability, less crime, and fewer dilapidated buildings. 

Explore the full story to see how tactful civic engagement just moved our government to voluntarily keep $7 million in the hands of taxpayers.

WATCH: CCG TAX APPRAISER SAYS QUIET PART OUT LOUD IN HEATED UNFILTERED COMMENT

This story was originally published on June 29, 2023.

An artistic expression of the Columbus Consolidated Government’s Chief Tax Appraiser, Suzanne Widenhouse, superimposed on a colorized image of the June 27 city council meeting. During the meeting, Widenhouse disturbingly stated during a heated unfiltered moment of stress that she is ‘not a fan of tax exemptions’ and that if she had her way there ‘wouldn’t be a single exemption available to anybody.’ Muscogee Muckraker

COLUMBUS, Ga. — A heated and unfiltered moment of stress led to a wildly-revealing and disturbing series of comments from a city official during the recent city council meeting held on June 27.

During a fiery debate regarding council’s move to lower the property tax millage rate — which ultimately kept $7 million in the pockets of taxpayers — CCG’s Chief Tax Appraiser, Suzanne Widenhouse, revealed her true feelings about tax exemptions here in Muscogee County.

Tax exemptions are a well-needed and long-established staple of our local economy that provide relief to the elderly, surviving spouses, disabled veterans, and many others. You can read more about our county’s property tax exemptions through the Tax Assessor’s Exemptions website here.

Nonetheless, Widenhouse let her true colors bleed through when placed on-the-spot by council to provide answers she quite clearly did not want to provide.

Widenhouse’s disturbing comments were as follows as she yelled at council members in an obvious moment of unfiltered stress:

“I’m not a fan of tax exemptions,” said the county’s Chief Tax Appraiser. “Personally, if it was up to me and I had my way, there wouldn't be a single exemption available to anybody; it’d make my life a whole lot easier.”

Fortunately for the citizens of Muscogee County, Widenhouse doesn't get her way. Her comments, however, revealed on their face her viciously-vehement personal bias against property tax exemptions.

Explore the full story to watch your Chief Assessor say just about the one thing a tax assessor shouldn’t say on camera.

CCG CONFIRMS: MAYOR LACKED AUTHORITY TO APPOINT POLICE CHIEF WITHOUT COUNCIL’S VOTE

This story was originally published on May 25, 2023 and was republished on June 30, 2023.

An artistic expression of Columbus Georgia’s mayor, Skip Henderson, superimposed on a colorized image of the city’s public safety building. The Columbus Consolidated Government recently confirmed that Henderson lacked the legal authority to unilaterally appoint the city’s new police chief and overstepped his bounds by doing so without an approving vote from City Council. Image source: Muscogee Muckraker

COLUMBUS, Ga. — The Columbus Consolidated Government just confirmed that Mayor Henderson has indeed overstepped his legal authority by unilaterally appointing a chief of police without first receiving a vote of approval from City Council.

In an email thread with CCG, we asked point blank what section of the City Charter provides the Mayor with the authority to appoint a chief of police.

The answer we received from CCG cited the exact scenario we previously published: that pursuant to Section 4-201, paragraph 15, the Mayor can only appoint a chief of police if City Council has given their approval through a majority vote of six council members.

In CCG’s own words, as shown through their own provided citations of the city’s Code of Ordinances in the email chain below, CCG is well aware that Mayor Henderson did not have the legal authority to unilaterally appoint a chief of police — for any length of tenure — without first receiving an approving vote from City Council.

Without the approval of City Council, no appointment of a chief of police can be made. Since no vote was ever recorded, there technically is no current police chief for our city, creating a massive legal liability for any action taken by Stoney Mathis on behalf of the office.

Despite city council members’ known frustration with the Mayor’s tyrannical overreach, no member of City Council has taken any public action to correct the matter nor to hold the Mayor accountable.

Explore the full story to see the entire email thread for yourself in CCG’s own words, proving our city currently does not have a legally-appointed police chief.

CCG WASTES RESOURCES; PASSES LAW SO 24 PEOPLE CAN RIDE GOLF CARTS ACROSS VETERANS PKWY

This story was originally published on July 1, 2023.

An artistic expression of a ‘golf cart crossing’ sign superimposed on a colorized image of the Columbus, Georgia city council meeting held on June 27. City officials have dedicated excessive resources to permit a mere 24 individual residents to drive their golf carts through one of the busiest and most dangerous intersections in the city, which includes a state highway. Council has now approved the plan. Image source: Muscogee Muckraker

COLUMBUS, Ga. — After frivolously dedicating hundreds of hours of time and countless resources from several key city departments, the city’s small number of registered golf cart owners will now be able to cross Veterans Parkway at its intersection with 14th Street. The vote occurred during the city council meeting on June 27. 

After eight years of encouraging the use of golf carts throughout the downtown area, there are still only 24 individual people with registered golf carts throughout the entire city.

The city’s recent push to make golf carts a ‘thing’ despite eight years of the market overwhelmingly rejecting the notion is allegedly geared toward ‘connecting’ the downtown area with the expansive efforts that have taken place across the state highway. 

All but one city councilor voted to approve the ordinance. Councilor Judy Thomas (District 9) held firm to her weeks of strong opposition to the idea and firmly cast her proud vote of no. You can read more about Councilor Thomas’ rational and diligent reasoning later on in this article.

The ordinance states that registered ‘personal transportation vehicles’ (golf carts) may be driven only on the following public street segments, which explicitly prohibits travel on 13th Street. We’ve placed the city’s provided map below the bullet list for clarity.

  • Bay Avenue between 10th Street and 12th Street. 
  • Front Avenue between 5th Street and 14th Street.
  • Broadway between 4th Street and 14th Street.
  • 1st Avenue from 4th Street to 13th Street.
  • 2nd Avenue from the north curb of Victory Drive to 9th Street.
  • 3rd Avenue from 4th Street to the south curb of 13th Street.
  • 3rd Avenue from 14th Street to the north curb of 13th Street
  • 5th Avenue between 13th Street and 15th Street.
  • 6th Avenue between 13th Street and 15th Street.
  • 5th Street between Front Avenue and the west curb of Veterans Parkway.
  • 6th Street between Front Avenue and the west curb of Veterans Parkway.
  • 7th Street between Front Avenue and the west curb of Veterans Parkway.
  • Chapel Street between 2nd and 3rd Avenue
  • 8th Street between Front Avenue and the west curb of Veterans Parkway.
  • 9th Street between Front Avenue and the west curb of Veterans Parkway.
  • 10th Street between Bay Avenue and the west curb of Veterans Parkway.
  • 11th Street between Bay Avenue and the west curb of Veterans Parkway.
  • 12th Street between Bay Avenue and the west curb of Veterans Parkway.
  • 14th Street between 6th Avenue and the cul-de-sac at the Frank Martin Pedestrian Bridge.
  • 15th Street between 5th Avenue and 6th Avenue.
A map produced by the Columbus Consolidated Government of roadways now approved for use by the city’s 24 registered golf cart owners in the downtown area of Columbus, Georgia. The golf carts will now be permitted to cross Veterans Parkway at its 14th Street intersection, which is one of the busiest and most dangerous intersections in the city. Image source: Muscogee Muckraker via CCG

Why the city believes having 24 individual local residents occasionally drive their golf carts across a state highway will somehow benefit the region remains unclear — and that’s probably because it clearly absolutely won’t. Not even a little bit.

For a greater context of how ridiculous the city’s level of misprioritization is:

More people have been shot to death in Columbus so far this year than the number of registered golf carts.

Explore the full story to see the laughable backstory behind council’s vote for the gain of a privileged few in the Historic District as the rest of the city crumbles around the microscopic downtown area.

THE WEEK AHEAD

The Columbus City Council is not scheduled to meet this week. The next regularly-scheduled meeting is set to be held on Tuesday, July 11, 2023 at 9:00 a.m. on the second floor of the C. E. “Red” McDaniel City Services Center located at 3111 Citizens Way, Columbus, GA 31906.

City offices will be closed in observance of Independence Day with various departments either shut completely or using an alternative schedule from July 3-4. The closures are as follows:

  • Property Tax & Motor Vehicle Office: Closed July 3-4
  • Animal Control: Closed July 3-4.
  • Recorder’s Court: Open only for Advisement Sessions & Jail Cases at 8:00 a.m. both days.
  • Metro Bus Service: Open July 3; Closed July 4.
  • Civic Center: Closed July 3-4.
  • Parks & Recreation: Office closed July 3-4; Lake Oliver open both days; Cooper Creek Tennis open July 3; Columbus Aquatic Center is open July 3, but alt. schedule July 4 from 6:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m.

A Look At Personal Safety

As the Columbus Police Department continues to unify under its new leadership model, violent crime is still likely to exist at higher levels than we would all like —  even in what have previously been thought of as the “safer parts” of our city.

We at the Muckraker want to encourage our readers and their loved ones to remain hyper-vigilant as they go about their daily lives. 

Based on  lifetimes of experience and the combined professional careers of us at the Muckraker and our associates, here are what we consider to be the most important ways Columbusites can make themselves “hard targets” to avoid becoming a crime victim:

  1. Situational Awareness: Be aware of your surroundings at all times. Keep your head on a swivel. Don’t walk around with headphones in. Keep your eyes moving and scanning around you as you move about.
  2. Trust Your Gut: If something inside of you is telling you that something isn’t right, trust that feeling. For example: If you’re parking your car at night and your gut tells you the dark shady spot next to the alley isn't the best place to park, don't park there. Your intuition is often more powerful and protective than you think.
  3. Move With Confidence: Think about this one for a minute. Are criminals going to target the guy or gal who struts hard down the street like a freaking lion patrolling their own domain, or are they going to leave that hard target the heck alone? Keep your head up. Move from place to place with a purpose. Don't walk around with your face in your phone with your purse wide open. Don’t look weak. Look dangerous

Back Our Blue

In closing, we at the Muckraker would like to thank the outstanding men and women of the Columbus Police Department who continue to shell out for the safety and well-being of our city each and every day, despite the abhorrent temporary conditions they are currently forced to work within.

“All police officers are entitled to outstanding leadership.”

Our city cannot thank you enough for what you do for us.

If you’re out and about throughout the week and see one of our city’s brave and valiant police officers, be sure to thank them. We’d bet it would mean an awful lot to them.

Residents are strongly encouraged to express their concerns and condolences for the brave men and women of the Columbus Police Department by emailing Mayor Skip Henderson directly at SkipHenderson@columbusga.org, while cc’ing their respective city council members on the email. 

Facts are stubborn things — and we’ll keep publishing them, whether city officials like them or not.

-30-

© 2023 Muscogee Muckraker. All rights reserved.

Be sure to follow Muscogee Muckraker on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter to see all the muck that’s fit to print as it breaks throughout the coming week. 

Got A Story?
We want to help you expose it.
GET IN TOUCH
Become a Muckraker Supporter
You can help us expose corruption.
Become a supporter today.
Get On The List
Not ready to subscribe?
We understand.

Join our mailing list and get
FREE limited access to our top headlines anyway.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.